Plot Twist(67)

“Shit,” she muttered to herself. Had Poppy just seen Sophie in her brother’s room in nothing but a bra?



28

DASH

When Dash opened the door and saw Poppy holding a Tupperware container, he felt a few things. First, annoyance that she’d shown up at the absolute worst possible time, and then an overwhelming sense of guilt. Because Sophie was Poppy’s best friend, and he’d wedged himself between them.

“Bone broth!” She smiled brightly as she held up the container. “I had extra in my fridge and just figured that since we’re doing the random stopovers I would bring you some. It does wonders for the digestive system.”

Poppy breezed past him in oversize jeans and a plain white T-shirt, her long blond hair swishing as she walked. She’d been thinking of him, and he hadn’t so much as considered how his actions were about to change her life.

She went into the kitchen and put the broth on the countertop, then she opened his cabinets until she found a mug. “Oh, this is so cute. Who knew you had taste?” She rotated the mug—his design—and appraised it with an appreciative look. It would be the perfect time to tell her he’d made it, if he didn’t need her to leave. “The broth makes an excellent snack. I’ll heat some for you. There should be enough here to last the next two days.”

He could not think of anything less appealing than a cup of hot bone broth as a snack, but he would keep those thoughts to himself. Especially because he wanted to get her out of his house before she realized Sophie was there.

“I can heat that up.” He quickly moved to take the mug from her, and she let him. Maybe if he just drank the damn thing she’d leave.

“Ew, Dash, what’s that on your hands?” She eyed the clay still dotting his hands. “Were you gardening?”

“Uh, yeah,” he lied, the same way he always did whenever his family got close to learning something real about him.

“Well, wash them before you get your sod, or whatever, all over the place.” She took the mug back from him.

He was about to make an excuse for why she had to leave, but then there was a crash from his bedroom. He winced, and Poppy turned toward the noise.

“Oh, no, don’t tell me you have someone here? Gross.” Poppy’s nose wrinkled, but she walked toward his bedroom because she couldn’t help but be her nosy self.

“It’s probably just the wind.”

“It’s as hot as a sauna outside. There’s no wind...” Poppy trailed off as her eyes caught on something. He followed her line of sight as she bent down and picked up one of Sophie’s sandals, then her dress. She held them at eye level and her face shifted from curious to confused. “Aren’t these Sophie’s?”

He didn’t answer. He couldn’t. He was frozen in place from fear that he’d just completely destroyed his sister’s trust, and he had no words that would make the situation okay. In his silence, though, Poppy advanced toward his bedroom.

He took a step to try to stop her, but then his door creaked open. Sophie held on to the frame and looked over at Poppy. She wore a long T-shirt of his that just skimmed above her knee, and he wasn’t quite sure, but he thought he saw a tremble in Sophie’s hands.

“Sophie?” Poppy’s voice went up in surprise, and then she turned to Dash. Her expression went from dazed to hurt as she began to understand exactly what was going on.

“Hey.” Sophie cleared her throat, then tried again. “Hi there.”

Poppy’s shoulders shrunk in on themselves. “Sophie, please, please, please tell me I’m jumping to conclusions about seeing you in my brother’s clothes and walking out of his bedroom.”

Sophie shot Dash a look, but her expression was unreadable, which made Poppy glance over, too. He knew he should say something to smooth the situation, but all he could come up with was “You should’ve texted before coming.”

Well, he knew that wasn’t the right thing.

“You mean so that you could both put the correct clothes on?” Poppy’s eyes narrowed, her hand was in a fist on her hip, and she leaned forward like one wrong move and she’d lunge for his throat.

“Poppy, this just kind of happened.” Sophie’s hands gestured between herself and Dash. “We didn’t plan for this.”

“You’re with my best friend, and you’re with my brother?” She pointed between them. “And neither of you thought to tell me? How long has this been going on?”

Dash was about to open his mouth to say something, but Poppy continued, “What, you thought I just wouldn’t find out?”

“We didn’t do this to hurt you,” Dash added. “It’s not Sophie’s fault. I started—”

But Poppy wheeled toward him with a raised and accusatory finger. “Do you realize how fucked up this is that you were both keeping the fact that you’re...” Poppy seemed to dry heave but then course-corrected.

“I know this looks bad,” Dash began to say, but Poppy stopped him with her hand.

“Just so you know, I stole ginger from your garden the last time I was here and didn’t tell you. I added it to the bone broth because I felt guilty. So I hope you enjoy that super-healing, yummy broth, because it’s the last time I’ll be making it for you!”