You tell her that’s not funny and she tells you to stop being such a worrywart and this is adorable—I love our family—and then an oaf in a T-shirt stomps up the stairs and into the frame and Nomi points at this oaf like she knows him.
“Look at Dad,” she says. “He’s wearing a T-shirt and shorts and he’s fine.”
The word Dad is an iceberg and there is no dad. Dad is gone. Dad isn’t on your Instagram and Nomi has never said the word Dad and our ship is taking on water. Fast.
“Hey, Phil,” you say. “Husband of the Year, will you tell your daughter to put a hat on?”
Dad has a name—it’s Phil—and I am Leo in the ice water, I will freeze to death on this boat, in this water. The man you call Phil, husband—this is not happening—he shushes you and our ship is cruising, we are sinking—and he’s a rock ’n’ roll type of ass and you are Married. Buried.
No, Mary Kay. No.
You don’t have a husband—but you do—and this guy isn’t husband material—but he is—and he’s not Eddie Vedder and it’s not 1997 so why is he sitting there with his feet up—Doc Martens—wiping his slimy hands on his Mother Love Bone T-shirt while he dictates God knows what into his phone? He pecks you on the cheek—and you let him kiss you—and the ballroom on this boat is flooded and the water is cold—and you touch him. His face. You casually break every bone in my body and pull a sweater from your purse.
He won’t take the sweater and I can’t take this. Won’t take this.
Married. Buried.
You must think I’m a moron. The Mothballs didn’t tell me and Melanda didn’t tell me and Seamus didn’t tell me and your little community is a clique of mean-spirited liars but fuck me because this is what I get for being Mr. Goody Two-shoes because since when do I rely on strangers to tell me the truth about the people I love? You’re married. You really are. He’s whining about your upcoming trip to Phoenix right now and he sleeps in a bed with you and we can’t hang out like a family today because he is your fucking family. Not me.
Married. Buried.
He holds up a bag of chips and Nomi claps her hands and I snap a picture of the motherfucker and there’s a tattoo on his leg and the ink is black: Sacriphil. I remember that band, barely, one of those nineties, not-quite-Nirvana groups and WHY THE FUCK DIDN’T I GOOGLE YOU ON DAY FUCKING ONE?
Your husband is an overgrown fan boy in dirty cargo shorts and he has bad taste in tattoos and he produces another bag of potato chips like some third-rate magician—I hate magic—and I hate him and right now, worst of all, I relate to Nomi because I hate you, Mary Kay. You lied to me. You want Phil’s chips and you wave him on and I remember you in the bathroom of the pub, when you were mine, when you kissed me. He tosses the chips to you and you catch the bag like you’re in a bridal party, like it’s a bouquet.
Married. Buried.
This is why you ran away from me and this is why we’ve been treading water and Nomi screams at the top of her lungs. “Dad! Come look!”
Your husband is an iceberg and I can’t take it anymore. This is the story of my life. Everything that should be mine, everyone, they’re all snatched away from me. I lost my son and I’ve tried so hard to be decent. Good. I’ve tried to forget all the Shel Silverstein poems I memorized when I was incarcerated, when I thought I’d actually get to be a dad, and now you do the same. You steal my shot at family and I can’t forgive you, the same way I can’t forget those fucking poems. You used me, Mary Kay. Love stole my son, but you have stolen my dignity, my self-respect, and I should have staked out your house the day we met.
Everything looks different now. You weren’t hazing me at the diner. You were playing fast and loose, weren’t you? You thought one of your Friends might say something about your husband in passing. And that’s why you were looking around in the pub so much on our date. You were afraid we’d get caught. You’re a dishonest woman. You don’t wear a wedding ring and you criticize your mother for her sham of a divorce but what the hell do you call this?
Your husband’s angry teenage boy outfit is embarrassing—you must be the breadwinner—and okay. I never directly asked if you’re married but that’s because you’re my boss. And okay, it would have been presumptuous of you to passive-aggressively declare your marital status—So my husband loved the Lisa Taddeo book—because that’s not your style. But who the fuck are we kidding?
Your husband would never read the Lisa Taddeo book. He’s not a reader. I can tell and you are right, Mary Kay. We see what we want to see and I didn’t want to see it. Same way I didn’t want to believe that Love was capable of stealing my child.
I grab the railing. The ship hasn’t sunk just yet. Yes, you’re married, but if your marriage was any good, you wouldn’t be so into me. I can still save us. I google you—I should have done this weeks ago—and there you are, Mary Kay DiMarco and oh no, oh no. Your husband isn’t a fan of that fucking band. He is in the band, the lead singer—of course—and Google knows his name because Phil DiMarco was that guy who sang that song.
You’re the shark inside my shark, you’re the second set of teeth and I just die underneath.
I’m the one who dies underneath because that’s you on the cover of his album and the history is sinking in, sinking our ship. Those are your legs under your black tights and gender-reveal parties are nothing compared to this big reveal—It’s a dad! It’s a husband! It’s a has-been rock star in shorts!
We’re getting close to the dock and I’m not gonna be intimidated by your husband. You were his muse and you’re not my muse. I respect you as a person. And okay, so he was kinda semifamous but he would never be in a clue on Jeopardy! and I’d rather be your work husband than the husband you loathe so much that you can’t even speak of him in casual conversation.
He walks up to you and puts his arms around you, and again, the boat is flooded and the water is cold, but I won’t let it get to me. I will not fucking freeze to death. You are telling him he needs to put on a sweater—I know you—and it’s mind-bending to see you like this. Married. Buried. How long did you think you could get away with this, Mary Kay?
We’re slowing down and you’re searching for something in your purse, and I bet you’ve been winging it because that’s what you do—Nomi was “the surprise of your life”—and before I came into your life, you were on cruise control. You married a music man and I’m sure you loved him at first. You were his tiny dancer and foxes do like attention—your body parts are on the cover of his album—but times change. You told me that you never understood why your mother left your father. You called it a sham divorce. That’s why you’re still in the cage with Phil. You don’t know how to leave that rat, do you?
Nobody in your family is hungry, but you’re rummaging through your purse. You pull an Ani Katz book out of your purse—I told you to read that one!—and you pause. You’re thinking about me. You want me. And then you shove it back in your purse and I feel guilty because you must be constantly worried about what happens when the book is out of the bag, when I find out about your life, when Phil finds out about me.