There were patterns, things that matched.
And then a piece of luck. DNA evidence at the Stevenson home matched evidence at the Behr home. Unfortunately, that DNA evidence did not match anything in the database of known criminals. Another dead end.
But new data was added every day; every six months or so, Hunter would request a new search to find a match. He was past due for a request to the department. He’d have to call in a favor; he wasn’t on the payroll for this case. There was no budget for a ten-year-old case. It had become his personal thing, a grudge match that he could not let go.
He opened his computer and searched out the news story he’d seen earlier today and pulled up the picture of the missing woman.
Looking back and forth between the image of Grace Stevenson from his file and his screen, he couldn’t be sure. People change—especially kids. Especially people who want to change. So many years. The young woman on the screen had a narrower face, her hair was darker. Some of the sweetness was gone. But around the mouth and the eyes, it could be. It might be Grace.
The Naughty Nanny.
He opened his file on Charles Finch. It held a single photograph, taken from among Stella Behr’s possessions. Heavily lashed blue eyes, defined cheekbones, clean-shaven, a wide, smiling mouth. Not just handsome. Beautiful in that way that some men were. Even other men saw it. A pretty boy, they’d call him on the playground or in the joint. Smallish, angular. Even the photograph radiated charm. The number one most important quality every con must have—the ability to charm and disarm. And this man was a con if Hunter ever saw one.
Hunter had his theory. That he was a guy who worked his way into the lives of vulnerable women. Maybe he wanted their money; and maybe sometimes that’s all he took. But sometimes maybe he wanted something more. And sometimes he took that, too.
He opened another file, this one filled with articles printed from the internet. He regularly scoured the web for cold cases that matched the pattern. There was a case in Tucson, where a woman was dating a man who tried to strangle her, but she was saved by a neighbor who heard her screams. She had a teenage daughter who was out for the evening. Her assailant got away. She only had a single picture of him. It might have been the man Hunter knew as Finch, but the picture was grainy and indistinct. The man looked heavier, wore glasses and a full beard. There was a slew of sweetheart scams, online predators convincing wealthy widows and widowers to wire money for this emergency or that. It happened a lot. There were a lot of grifters out there, lots of victims. More than anyone knew.
There was one in Phoenix, a woman named Bridget Pine who said she was nearly scammed by a man and his daughter. She and the man—who she knew as Bill Jackson—had been having an online relationship when he claimed his daughter had been in an accident and he needed money. She’d been suspicious, she said. Then she ran a few checks, checking up on details like where he supposedly lived and worked, quickly realizing almost everything he told her was a lie. She reported him to the authorities—local police and the FBI. She alerted the media. But, like Charles Finch, he was a ghost; disappeared without a trace. The picture she had of him from his online profile did not resemble Finch; there was no image of the girl.
Most people who were victims of the sweetheart scam just slunk away; it was a humiliation, the death of a dream. But Bridget Pine raised a fuss and when Hunter called her, she detailed for him everything that had transpired. The passionate emails, the late-night phone calls, the delicious tension of awaiting their first meeting. She wasn’t a beautiful woman; so, the ability to get to really know someone before meeting—she thought that it was a truer connection.
“The physical shell doesn’t matter,” she told him. “It’s what’s inside that counts, isn’t it?”
“Of course,” said Hunter. But intimacy was about more than late-night conversations and promises. He thought of his own marriage—imperfect, enduring, how you had to accept every facet of each other, even the things you didn’t like.
“On some level,” she said, “I guess I knew. I’d given up on love and romance. But something about the online dating. It felt safer. I didn’t think it would hurt as much if it didn’t work out.”
“I’m sorry,” he told her. “This happens a lot. More than you know.”
“How do I find him?” she asked. “Can you help me? I can pay you.”
“I’ve been looking for him—or someone like him—for years. You don’t have to pay me. If I find him, you’ll be my first call.”
“How have you been looking for him?” she asked.
He told her his techniques of scanning news sites, following up with similar stories, cold calling. Sometimes taking a road trip.
“All it takes is one detail that leads you somewhere new,” he said. “But my advice? Just let it go, move on.”
She laughed a little. “I don’t have anything to move on to. Bill—I think he was my last chance for love.”
Bill. Charlie. Whoever. He wasn’t even real.
“If you get a lead,” he said, “don’t follow it up on your own, call me. Let me help. No charge.”
She promised that she would. This was a couple of months before Maggie Stevenson was murdered, her daughter Grace disappeared.
Later, Bridget Pine walked off the face of the earth. She bought a new car, quit her job, cashed out some accounts, packed a bag and slipped away from her life. When he couldn’t reach her—email bounced, phone disconnected—Hunter called around, finally finding a former coworker who knew her a little.
“She was an odd duck,” he said. “She kept to herself. Then, one day, she just quit. She said she’d made enough money to retire and she wanted to travel. It was—odd.”
No one had ever heard from her again.
Hunter kept reading through his old notes. Then scanned the various news sources for all the information he could get on the Naughty Nanny, and then he scanned through the cold case websites he liked. He was looking for it, the one thing, that connected all of them. The one piece of information that would lead him on a fresh trail.
The sun set and the lamps came on outside. Hunter knew there was about an hour before his wife came home. Until she did, he’d spend a little time on Stella and Pearl Behr, Maggie and Grace Stevenson. He’d keep looking. Because everybody counts.
TWENTY-EIGHT
Selena
She pulled the blinds and pretended there was no one out on her lawn, on her driveway, on the street. As the detective left, a handful of reporters, a couple of news vans, a few other unmarked vehicles had come to gather around her house. Neighbors were at their windows and on their porches. It wasn’t a mob. But the sight of the strangers filled her with dread. Now, Selena was one of those people, the ones you saw on the news, their lives in a shamble because of scandal or a crime.
She sank onto the couch, not sure of what to do. Pack. That was it. She needed to gather her things and more clothes and toys for the boys. She needed to leave this house and go home to her mother. Because—what else? Where else?
When there was an aggressive knocking on the door, she sat frozen. The detective again? The police coming to take her in? Her heart thumped. She waited. Maybe they’d go away.