Instead of leaving evidence, my father was taking it.
* * *
“Even if it could save a life, Chloe?”
I watched the sweat drip down Sheriff Dooley’s neck. He was staring at me with an intensity I had never seen before. He was staring at me, and he was staring at the box clutched in my hands.
“If you hand over that box, you could save a life. Think about that. What if someone could have saved Lena’s life, but chose not to because they were afraid of stirring up trouble?”
I looked down at my lap, nodded slightly. Then I thrust my arms forward before I had time to change my mind.
The sheriff wrapped his gloved hands around mine, the rubber slippery but warm, before pulling the box gently from my grip. He looked down at the lid before placing his fingers on the lip and opening it wide, the sound of chimes filling the room. I avoided his expression, instead choosing to stare at the ballerina, twirling in slow, perfect circles.
“It’s jewelry,” I said, my eyes still on the dancing girl. It was mesmerizing, watching her spin in that faded pink tutu, her arms raised high. She reminded me of Lena, the way she twirled at the festival.
“I see that. Do you know who it belongs to?”
I nodded. I knew he was looking for more of an answer, but I couldn’t bring myself to say it. Not voluntarily, at least.
“Who does the jewelry belong to, Chloe?”
I heard a sob erupt from my mother beside me, and I glanced in her direction. Her hand was clamped over her mouth, her head shaking violently. She had already seen the contents of this box; I had shown it to her, back home. I had wanted her to give me an explanation other than the one that was forming in my own mind. The only explanation that made sense. But she couldn’t.
“Chloe?”
I looked back at the Sheriff.
“The belly-button ring is Lena’s,” I said. “Right there, in the middle.”
The sheriff reached into the jewelry box and plucked out the small, silver firefly. It looked dead, having spent weeks in the dark. No sunshine to fuel its glow.
“How do you know that?”
“I saw Lena wearing it at the Crawfish Festival. She showed it to me.”
He nodded, lowering it back into the box.
“And the others?”
“I know that pearl necklace,” my mother said, her voice wet. The sheriff glanced at her before reaching into the box again and lifting up a string of pearls. They were large, pink, and tied together in the back with a ribbon. “That belongs to Robin McGill. I … I saw her wearing it. At church one Sunday. I commented on how much I liked it, how unique it was. Richard was with me. He saw it, too.”
The sheriff exhaled, nodding again before placing it back inside. Over the next hour, the rest of the jewelry would come to be identified—Margaret Walker’s diamond earrings, Carrie Hollis’s sterling silver bracelet, Jill Stevenson’s sapphire ring, Susan Hardy’s white gold hoops. There was no DNA found on anything—they had been meticulously cleaned, the box wiped down—but their parents confirmed our suspicions. They had been presents for eighth-grade graduations, confirmations, birthdays. Tokens meant to celebrate the milestones of their girls growing up, instead forever memorialized by their untimely deaths.
“This is helpful, Chloe. Thank you.”
I nodded, the rhythm from the chimes soothing me into a kind of stupor. Sheriff Dooley slapped the lid closed, and I jerked my head up, the trance broken. He was staring at me again, his hand placed on top of the closed box.
“Did you ever witness your father interacting with Lena Rhodes or any of the other missing girls?”
“Yes,” I said, my mind flashing back to the festival. The way he was staring at her and her long, smooth stomach. The way he ducked his head when he realized he was caught. “I saw him watching her once at the Crawfish Festival. When she was showing me her belly-button ring.”
“What was he doing?”
“Just … staring,” I said. “She had her shirt pulled up. She caught him looking, and she waved.”
My mother scoffed beside me, shook her head.
“Thank you, Chloe,” the sheriff said. “I know this wasn’t easy for you, but you did the right thing.”
I nodded.
“Before we let you go, is there anything else you’d like to tell us about your father? Anything that might be important for us to know?”
I exhaled, held myself tightly in my own arms. It was hot in there, but suddenly, I felt myself shiver.
“I saw him with a shovel once,” I said, avoiding my mother’s stare. This was news to her. “He was walking across our yard, coming from the swamp behind our house. It was dark, but … he was there.”