I offered them five dollars from my purse. They refused it, so I put in an extra twenty. They took that. It chilled me to know that was the price—that would be the price—of pride once Graham and Margo were through with me: twenty-five dollars. Not even enough to buy a jug of milk, probably.
The prospect of going home to Graham, telling him what happened, is humiliating. He’ll make me tell Margo. She’ll say she was right. I’m not like them. I don’t belong. And what if Graham believes it? What if he decides she’s right? Game over.
I can’t deny that things have not been going well with Graham for a while. Maybe from the beginning. But like other couples have children or jobs or hobbies to distract them from their imperfect pairing, Graham has the game. I let him play. I tolerated it. I didn’t interfere. Until Elvira. That is when the tide well and truly turned. That was why they decided it needed to be my turn. Graham needs me to prove that I’m on his side, needs me to prove that we are the same after all.
But what if we aren’t the same? What if that isn’t the reason I fell for him? What if, like every woman ever, I wanted him, needed him, to change? And he can’t. He won’t.
Why was I ever even friends with Elvira at all? I knew I was interfering, knew it wouldn’t last. Yet I kept on going to her, out for our walks, down for drinks, out shopping. I put myself in Graham’s way. I knew what I was doing. I didn’t want him to destroy her. I wanted her to win. I thought that she was different. She was, just not in the way I thought.
She slit her wrists with a Buck knife from the toolshed, the one with silver horses engraved on the handle. Just that afternoon, we had walked around the reservoir together.
We talked about Graham.
She told me he had kissed her. I told her that was okay. We had an open relationship.
“We’re practically divorced,” I said. “It’s just so complicated when money is involved.”
“But you love him,” she said, insistent.
“It’s just so complicated when money is involved,” I repeated in jest, but she didn’t laugh.
“You should leave him,” she said. It was the first time any of the tenants had warned me. It hit funny, knowing I should warn her. “You’re too good for him.”
“I’m not. I’m exactly the right amount of bad for him.” I remember this distinctly, my trying to turn everything into a joke, her turning it gently back.
“No. You’re too good.”
She was wrong. Wrong and now dead. I’m not too good. I’m not good at all. I’m a bad person and I have to stay bad. I don’t have a choice. I have to keep playing.
It’s like Demi said: The game never ends. Playing is the reward.
I turn east toward home.
I will shower. I will put myself back together. I will sit in the corner at the place where two windows meet and I will design a way to win.
LYLA
The gate is still gone, away with the monks, being prayed over. I cross through the courtyard, ignore the laughter from the fountain. My hair is greasy. My cashmere is bobbly. My mascara dust is sprinkled under my eyes. I look mad. I look like the housekeeper.
I put my key in the front door, but it’s unlocked. I push it open. Graham is standing at the window. He wheels around, rushes toward me.
“Where have you been?” His face is pale. Sweats hang from his hips.
“I thought you were at work,” I say.
His arms grow around me, pull me tight against his chest, where I can feel his racing heart. His scent drenches me, atomized by worry. “I was just about to call the police.” He brushes my hair down, over and over, like he is trying to revive me. “My beautiful wife. I was so worried about you.”
All I can think is You’re supposed to be at work, you’re supposed to be at work. “I need to take a shower.”
He steps back, presses his finger pads into my shoulders. “Where were you?”
All those hours walking and I never thought he would be here. I never thought he would be worried. Even now it’s hard to determine whether this is real or whether it’s a tactic, whether he is running a secret game.
“It’s silly, really.” I don’t want to tell him, don’t want to admit that I failed, but they will find out eventually. I will need him to pay the fine. “I got arrested.”
His jaw goes limp. “Arrested?” The word is zesty on his tongue. He follows me to the bathroom with awestruck eyes. “What did you get arrested for?”
“Trespassing.” I start to undress, turn on the shower.