“Not right now, Rachel,” Wendy said. She tried to get herself free of the little girl’s vicelike grip. “Me and my friend here need to go talk.” She gave Peter a pointed look and jerked her head toward the door.
Rachel whirled around to look at Peter, apparently just having noticed him. “Hello,” he said to her with a smile.
Wendy had never witnessed Rachel being as quiet as she was in the following moments.
Rachel studied Peter carefully, her eyebrows pulled together in concentration. Peter seemed completely unfazed. Wendy just stood there as the silence stretched out, long and awkward.
Wendy was about to ask Rachel if she was feeling all right when a big, gap-toothed smile broke across her face. “PETER!” she all but squealed, launching herself onto him.
“Rachel, no!” Wendy tried to pull her off, but Rachel kept wiggling free and grabbing hold of Peter’s shirt in her little hands.
Peter laughed, loud and bright.
“Wendy, it’s Peter Pan! You’re friends with Peter Pan?” She looked back and forth between the two of them. “Ooh, I knew you were real!” she told him as she yanked on his arm.
“See? Rachel here knows who I am,” Peter said with a smug look.
Wendy had to fight the urge to drag him out of there by his ear. She pointed a finger at him. “Not helping!” They were going to draw someone’s attention. “Rachel, that’s not Peter Pan. Peter Pan isn’t real—he’s just make-believe.” Though, she wasn’t convinced of that anymore.
The wounded look on his face almost made her regret saying it, but they really didn’t have time for this right now!
Regardless, Rachel wasn’t buying it. “Of course he’s real!” she said. She jerked her arm free from Wendy and squished Peter’s cheeks between her small hands. “See?”
Yes, she did see it. It was hard to not laugh at his smooshed face, but she did see it. The eyes, the chipped tooth, and the auburn hair. It was all there, whether she would openly admit it or not.
“He’s a bit old,” Rachel went on, as if this were a count against him. “But it’s still him. You can see it right there in his eyes!” she said, pointing. “And his mouth.” She poked his bottom lip. “And see, that’s the scar he got from fighting Captain Crash McCreevy!” She pointed to a V-shaped scar on his upper arm. The mention of Captain Crash McCreevy reminded Wendy of the Peter Pan story she’d told at least a dozen times. It was about a crazy old pirate captain who wanted to steal all the tiger cubs to make a blanket, until Peter challenged him to a harrowing duel. In the story, Captain Crash McCreevy fought Peter Pan with the nose of a swordfish that left a V-shaped cut in Peter’s arm.
The evidence sent Rachel into another bout of wiggly excitement. “It’s Peter Pan!”
“She makes valid points,” Peter confirmed, nodding his head.
“But, Peter, why are you so old?” Rachel asked, the smile on her face dimming with concern.
“Well, that’s something I’ve been trying to talk to Wendy about, but she seems to be having trouble believing me,” he told her.
Rachel gave Wendy an accusatory look.
Wendy scowled. The last thing she needed was Rachel telling everyone she’d met Peter Pan. But, apparently, Peter was already two steps ahead of her.
“Can you do me a favor, Rachel?” Peter asked as he leaned closer to her. Rachel nodded vigorously. “You can’t tell any adults I’m here, or I might get in trouble, okay? It needs to be a secret between the three of us—oh, and Alex here,” he added, nodding to Alex, who was still staring unblinkingly at the paper shark.
Rachel nodded solemnly. “I won’t. I promise. Will you come back and visit us again soon?”
“Yes—”
“No!” Wendy cut in, finally pulling Rachel away from Peter. “We need to talk now, Rachel. Go play with Alex.”
Peter stood up and mussed the top of Rachel’s already frizzy hair.
“Bye, Peter!” Rachel said, throwing her arms around him and giving him a hug before sliding into the seat next to Alex.
Wendy glared at Peter. “Let’s go,” she growled.
As she led Peter to the door, she overheard Alex tell Rachel, “He made it float!”
“Well, yeah, he’s Peter Pan!” Rachel replied.
Wendy walked as fast as she could down the hallway, dragging Peter along behind her, her hand clasped around his wrist. She kept looking around, paranoid that someone would spot them and Wendy would somehow get in trouble. She pulled him down the stairway and crossed the lobby to a glass door that opened up into an empty courtyard.