‘This is going to feel really messed up for a long time,’ I say. ‘But we’ll work it out because we have to, for the kids.’ I nod towards the ghoulish Halloween display we made together. ‘The kids needed to see that we were okay, and doing that together showed that, whatever happens, we are.’
‘I didn’t want you to find out about Robert the way you did, I really am so sorry. I wanted to tell you properly, myself, face to face. And I was going to – remember the day you came over and told us you were going away? I’d decided to tell you that day, but it felt wrong once you said you were leaving.’
I can’t lie – I wish she’d found the words. There’s no easy way to hear that the person you love is with someone else but three thousand miles away on a hill in the pouring rain was definitely the worst way. Of course, if she had told me about Robert then, there’s every possibility I wouldn’t have gone to Salvation at all. And if I hadn’t been to Salvation, a whole chunk of who I am now would be missing.
‘Robert wasn’t the reason, you know,’ Susie says. ‘He wasn’t the reason why. It happened months later. I didn’t even see it coming, it just …’ She shrugs. ‘I was low, and he was kind, and it just happened.’
I look at the floor. ‘I believe you.’ I do. I’d like to think there was enough honesty in our marriage for neither of us to have cheated.
‘I don’t even know if it’s anything yet,’ she says. ‘I know I said it was serious. I thought it was, got caught up in it, I guess. Too soon, I think.’
I can’t help but wonder what caused the setback for them. I’m pretty sure they didn’t play happy family the whole time at the lake but maybe he headed down there for a day. I find myself hoping that he’s a terrible fisherman.
‘Too soon to know?’
She looks at me then and a tear spills down her cheek. ‘Too soon after you, Mack Sullivan.’
I have to tell her about Cleo. It isn’t fair that she’s laying it on the line and I’m not.
‘Listen, Susie,’ I say, trying to pick the words that will hurt the least.
We both look up as a car eases to a stop just down the street. ‘Shit.’ Susie dashes her hands over her damp cheeks. ‘It’s Robert. I didn’t know he was coming.’
Ugh. I pinch the bridge of my nose as she jumps to her feet. I watch Robert get out of his sensible sedan, glad the kids aren’t here to watch this. Button-down vest. Check. Goofy tie. Check. Wary expression. Check. Sudden fury burning through my gut like acid? Check.
‘I should go,’ I mutter.
Susie turns to me. ‘Mack, you don’t have to …’
I can’t tell if she’s asking me to stay or to go. Way I see it, if I stay I might hit him, which would unpick all the good work we’ve done here this afternoon. I know I kind of forfeited the right to such indignation when I rubbed out that chalk line in Otter Lodge, but there’s no applying logic to the emotions running through my veins right now. I’ve known Robert for more than seven years. Has he always been sweet on Susie? Has he been hanging around in the wings, waiting for a crack to worm himself into? I’m angry with him in a way I’m not with Susie. I could pay a psychologist a small fortune to offer me a whole host of enlightened theories as to why this burns, or I could just listen to the wounded lion in my chest telling me this dude moved in on my pride when my back was turned and I should rip his fucking face off. I’m not proud of my feelings, but there they are.
‘I’m gonna head out,’ I say. ‘Tell the kids I’ll call them later.’
Robert slides back into his car in an almost comical reverse move as I take the porch steps two at a time. I don’t even look his way, just keep on going until I’m back in my truck, gunning the engine, getting myself out of there before I do anything stupid.
Later, I sit at the dining table, three beers in, photos of Salvation Island on my laptop in front of me. I’m framing it as work in my head, but what I’m really doing is looking for a way to ease the ache inside me. I’m reminding myself that life won’t always feel this hard, that there will be other places and other times, that I can slow dance to ‘Thunder Road’ under the stars and still be a good dad. I’ve picked at my own scabs over the last hour or so, scrolled through old photos of the kids when they were little, of Susie looking exhausted and beautiful in her hospital gown a couple of hours after Leo was born, of home-made birthday cakes and wobbly first steps. It’s so much to let go of, this love. Baby teeth and first curls tucked away in envelopes in a house I no longer live in, the tie I wore on the day I married Susie, folded into the box with her wedding dress in the attic. The romance of us tangled with the hot mess of parenting, diluting us and strengthening our bond all at the same time. I can’t shake the depressing weight of failure off my shoulders. Other people make it, why not us? I’ve spent long, sleepless nights turning that question over in my head, walking through the places when I didn’t do enough, when I didn’t say the right thing, and it’s futile. It’s hard work falling out of love when you don’t want to.