“What?” She looked nervous for a second. “Don’t be ridiculous.”
“You do, don’t you? You have a thing for my dad!” I started to laugh.
“Will you stop it? I do not!” She scrambled off the bed and backed up. “It was a joke!”
“Then why are you blushing?”
“I’m not blushing, I’m just—it’s not a thing, okay?” She began pacing back and forth at the foot of the bed. “Your dad is objectively a very attractive man.”
I grinned at her. “So you’re attracted to him?”
“No! I didn’t say that, I said objectively, he’s attractive,” she said quickly. “Anybody would find him attractive. It’s just biology. I just made a joke. That dream meant nothing.”
“What dream?”
“Shit!” She put her hands in her hair and squeezed her eyes shut. “I didn’t mean to say that!”
“Well, it’s out there now, so you might as well elaborate.” I leaned back against the pine-log headboard. “What happened in the dream?”
“Nothing.”
“Liar.”
Sighing, she faced me and held up her hands. “He kissed me, okay? That’s all. It was one kiss, and then I woke up.”
“Where were you? In the dream.”
Her face turned an even deeper shade of scarlet. “My bed.”
“So you’d let my dad and my brothers in your bed, but not me?”
“That’s not funny. And why is it suddenly so hot in here?” She turned away from me and fanned her face.
“It’s not hot in here. I think you’re just warm thinking about your crush on my dad.”
She spun around, flustered and frantic. “It’s not a crush! He was very nice to me when I was little, okay? I remember once when I was at your house in Detroit, before you moved up north, I fell and got a bloody knee and he came outside and carried me in. It’s a sweet memory.”
“It is a sweet memory. Except that it was me who carried you in the house.”
“What?” She stuck her hands on her hips. “No way, Gianni. We were like five years old.”
“I know. We were at my house, and you were trying to run faster than me down the driveway—which was never going to happen, by the way. You wiped out so hard you bloodied both knees. I felt bad for you and somehow I knew I was gonna get yelled at for it, so I thought I’d try to be nice and help you into the house.”
She was staring at me from across the room with her mouth open. Her eyes narrowed. “You’re lying.”
“I’m not,” I said, laughing. “That’s what actually happened.”
“I refuse to believe it. You’re just messing with my head. Like you always do.”
I shrugged. “Maybe this will just be another one of those things we remember differently.”
She lifted her chin. “Maybe so.”
The silence between us was thicker than the snow drift outside the windows.
“Are we ever going to talk about it?” I asked.
“About what?”
“You know what. Those seven minutes.”
“I don’t see what there is to talk about. Nothing happened.”
“Ellie, come on. It’s time to admit it—something happened.”
“Fine. What happened was you tricked me.”
“What?” I gaped at her. “I didn’t trick you!”
“Yes, you did!” Her eyes lit up with fury. “I said I wouldn’t kiss you, and you bet me you could change my mind in seven minutes.”
“And I did.” I was annoyed at the accusation that I’d done something shady, but I couldn’t help smiling. “I did change your mind in seven minutes, and I didn’t even break a single one of your rules.” I ticked them off on one hand. “I didn’t force you, I didn’t touch any private parts—I didn’t even talk. And before that timer went off, you begged me to kiss you.”
Seething, she drew herself up like the Queen of England. “I. Did not. Beg.”
I laughed. “Sorry. You told me to kiss you. Twice, in fact.”
“And you didn’t.”
“The seven minutes were up,” I said with a shrug, although that wasn’t exactly true.
She pointed a finger at me. “You had time to kiss me, and you know it. You just wanted to humiliate me. That’s all you ever want to do—tonight included!” She grabbed her bag off the floor and stomped off toward the bathroom in a huff. Before she got there, she whirled around once more. “And I didn’t beg!”