“Sit down,” Luna said, guiding Scarlet onto the edge of her bed. “Listen to me very carefully. Owen needs to be off-balance. He likes people to be puzzles. If he’s solved you, then he’s no longer interested.”
“So what am I supposed to do? Be mysterious?”
Luna hated the sound of that, a woman changing her ways to please a man. But it was the correct advice for Scarlet’s endgame.
“Don’t be anything you’re not. But don’t tell him everything that’s on your mind. Wait, stop. This isn’t good advice,” Luna said, again recalibrating. “If you have things on your mind that you want to express, you should say them.”
“No, this is great,” Scarlet said, already setting in motion a plan of action. “He doesn’t have to know everything I’m thinking, right?”
“That’s my motto,” Luna said.
If Scarlet was going to adopt any of her advice, Luna hoped it was that.
Scarlet played with her hair incessantly—scooping it behind her ears, grasping it in a ponytail and dropping it back down, twirling it around a finger and draping it over her shoulder. The touching, the stroking, the fidgeting, began to annoy Luna so deeply she had to stare at a distant wall.
“I have a paper to write,” Luna said, eyeing the door, hoping that Scarlet would get the hint.
“What do I do if he doesn’t call?” Scarlet asked.
“Wait him out,” Luna said.
“So I shouldn’t sleep with him again. At least not the next time he calls?”
“Yes. No. You should do what you want to do,” Luna said.
Luna felt a medley of uncomfortable emotions, including annoyance and jealousy. She was disappointed in herself for feeling hostile toward Scarlet. To compensate, she offered another, more specific piece of advice.
“If you sleep with him again, make sure you leave first.”
Over the next two months, Scarlet repeatedly came to Luna seeking counsel. She’d listen to Luna for a while and follow her advice to a T. Then she’d get comfortable, thinking that her relationship with Owen had finally found its footing, and slip up. Luna eventually gave up and told Scarlet to listen to her gut, just be herself. That was a good rule of thumb in general, but it wasn’t going to improve matters with Owen. Scarlet’s surprise visits to Owen’s dorm had increased in frequency. Her availability, as far as Owen was concerned, was limitless. Owen spent more time than usual at the library or in a local café just so he wouldn’t be home for Scarlet’s increasingly common drop-ins.
* * *
—
With a week left before winter break, Owen hoped to limit his Scarlet interactions. His dorm was no longer a safe place, and he’d grown tired of the unforgiving chairs in the library. Owen waited for Luna as she filed out of the Walter Hughes Humanities Building. Luna had just taken her Ethics exam, her brain still in the classroom. She didn’t even see Owen until he was standing right in front of her.
“What are you up to now?” Owen asked.
Luna didn’t want to answer the question. She glanced at her watch, just to buy time. “I got a thing,” she said.
“What kind of thing?” Owen said.
Luna should have known better than to offer a vague answer. Owen could never rest on an ambiguity.
“What is it with you and specifics?” Luna said. “I have an appointment. I’ll be gone for a few hours.”
Normally Owen would have kept pressing for details, but he had other priorities. “Can I borrow your room key?” he asked.
“Why?”
“I’m tired. I really need to take a nap,” Owen said.
“Who’s stopping you?” Luna said.
“Scarlet always drops by in the afternoon, and I need some me time.”
“Did you really just say that?”
“I did,” Owen replied, turning up his palm, waiting.
“You’ve been seeing Scarlet for how long now?”
“We’re not seeing each other,” Owen said. “It’s very casual.”
“Here’s the problem with having occasional sex with a woman for over two months,” Luna said. “She starts to think you like her, because it’s very unlikely that she would repeatedly hook up with someone that she doesn’t like. Now that you have that information, maybe you’ll think before you fuck.”
“I appreciate that insight,” Owen said. “Can you help me out?”
Luna was trying to figure out the best way to say no, but Owen pressed on. He was desperate.