His arm came around me, guiding me backward, toward the bedroom. As soon as the door was closed, I broke from him long enough to pull at the buckle of his belt.
His hand pressed to my back, holding me closer to him, and the other reached into the thin white fabric of my nightgown, finding my breast. I exhaled against his mouth, a small cry escaping me. Everywhere he touched me, every place he returned to, was screaming.
I pulled the nightgown over my head and dropped it to the floor. I didn’t want to wait. I couldn’t.
He kissed me deeper as we leaned back onto the bed, the weight of him pressing the air from my lungs. There was no fumbling. No awkward searching of hands. This wasn’t the breathless thrill of discovery. It didn’t have the mark of a first time.
This was a homecoming.
He pulled my leg up around him, and he groaned as we came together. My chest rose and fell beneath his, and he stilled for a moment, breaths slowing as his forehead rested against mine again. There was a tear sliding down the bridge of his nose.
“I love you,” he breathed.
My hands found his hips, holding him to me. I could feel him, not just inside of me. I could feel him in places that hadn’t yet taken shape—all of the images and feelings that were just out of reach.
We moved together like we’d done this hundreds of times, and we had. But we hadn’t. He’d never touched this body. These lips had never kissed him like this. It wasn’t gentle, and it wasn’t slow; it was deep and earnest. It was full of memories, and I chased them, breath for breath, before they could flicker away.
I’d been wrong about the June who came through that door five years ago. I’d hated her for the choice she made because I thought it was cruel. I thought it careless. But this aching love that was breaking ground inside of me didn’t feel selfish. It felt brave.
Twenty-Seven
We were quiet a long time. Long enough for morning to fully break over the fields and fill the room with light.
Eamon lay on his back with me fit against his side, and I pressed my closed mouth to his shoulder, my hand flat on his chest so that I could feel the heartbeat beneath his bones. With every thump, it was saying that he was real. This was real. It was happening.
I didn’t want to move, much less speak, afraid that I would disturb that sense of stillness that had found us. It was a fragile, precious thing. A calm that I didn’t want to believe would be followed by a storm.
Whatever this was, it wasn’t simple. I was trying to stitch together the fragments, pull them into one chronological timeline that told a story I could understand. But while the pieces were coming, they weren’t coming quickly, and none of them were in order.
I’d opened the red door like every Farrow had. I didn’t know that it would change my life forever. In my case, it had changed twice. Now there was one more choice to make, and the only one who could make it was me.
I could still feel the drag of Eamon’s touch across my skin. The heaviness of him between my legs. I could smell him in the sheets like I did that first day I woke with the warmth of his arms around me. There had been a part of me, even then, that was waking to this, like opening my eyes after a yearslong sleep.
What was so clear to me now was that Eamon was the only person who had ever really known me. Wholly. Completely. I’d been lucky to have people who loved me. Gran. Birdie. Mason. But there were parts of myself that I’d kept hidden away from them for their sakes as much as mine. I’d found a way to give it all to Eamon.
He was the only one who knew the things I really wanted. The only person I’d never kept them from. But as I lay there, listening to the sound of his breathing, I needed to know if I was that person for him, too.
“I need to ask you something,” I whispered.
His fingers sleepily wove through mine on his chest, holding my hand there. “Okay.”
I studied the boundary along his collarbone where the sun had darkened his skin. Once I asked it, I wouldn’t be able to put the words back into my mouth. Once I heard his answer, I wouldn’t be able to unknow it.
“Did you kill Nathaniel Rutherford?”
The question was a small one for the meaning it carried. But my voice didn’t waver, and I didn’t hesitate. I would remember, eventually, but I needed to know now. And I needed him to be the one to tell me.
He was still for a long moment before his weight shifted in the bed, and then he sat up, making my hand slip from where it was tucked against him. He raked his hair back, his feet touching the floor, and I bit the inside of my cheek.
He was shutting me out again. I could see it in the change of his posture. The way his eyes went to the corner of the room.
I pushed myself up behind him, fitting my body to his. My arms snaked around his middle, my skin pressed to him. He was rigid, but when I set my cheek against his shoulder blade, he relaxed just a little.
“Are you asking because you’re trying to decide what kind of man I am?”
“I’m asking because I want to know the truth. All of it.”
Eamon set his elbows on his knees and put his face into his hands, breathing through his fingers. When he looked up again, he was half-lit by the window. Slowly, he pulled my hand so that I slid to the edge of the bed beside him. His eyes stared right into mine.
“Are you sure about that?”
I knew that I was. “You can trust me,” I said, and I meant it. I didn’t know if there was anything he could say that would change that. Not now.
He fell silent again, his gaze moving over the room, as if he were trying to find the words. I waited, afraid that if I said anything else, he would change his mind. When he shifted, turning to face me, his hand came to my cheek, thumb tracing the curve of my bottom lip before it followed the line of my jaw.
I wasn’t sure what that look on his face was. Concern, or compassion, maybe. There was a gentleness, a caution, in his voice.
“I didn’t kill him, love,” he said. “You did.”
And as soon as the words left his mouth, I remembered.
Twenty-Eight
June 21, 1950
The flash of a bulb goes off, a crackling, fizzing sound that fills my head. The wash of the bright white light fades, and the soft glow of the tent settles back over me. The tinny strum of a banjo rings out, and bodies move on the dance floor; the wind catches my dress. The photographer snaps another photograph, and the bulb sizzles again.
I’m at the Midsummer Faire.
Laughter drifts through the syrupy air, and I smile when I see Margaret’s and Esther’s faces push through the crowd.
Margaret is out of breath, her face flushed from dancing. “Where’s Eamon?”
“At the house,” I answer. “Callie’s gotten out again.”
She frowns, eyes dropping to my shoulder. “You want me to take her?”
I glance down, just registering the warm, heavy weight I’m carrying. A small Annie is propped on my hip, her legs dangling and her arms curled into me. She’s asleep on my chest.
“That’s okay,” I say, thinking that I like this feeling, even though my arms are aching. I’ve been holding her for more than an hour.
Esther is already tying a scarf around her head. “You girls ready?”
We follow her out to the truck, the sound of the Faire bleeding away behind us, and we drive with the windows down. There’s a pastel sunset just beginning to gather over the mountains, and the fireflies are blinking when we pull up to the flower farm.