“Bravery?”
“Yes! For tonight,” she says.
“Why would I need to feel brave?”
“Well, for starters, you hate being the center of attention, and this is the first time the mainlanders will see you in their world, so they’ll be watching. It’s also kind of your debut as a couple, and you’ll be expected to dance. In front of everyone. It’s a lot.”
I take another sip of tea, much bigger than before. “You know, I wasn’t actually nervous until just now, so thanks for that.”
“No problem.” Ivy smiles and brings her teacup to her mouth.
“What are you drinking?” I ask, but before Ivy can answer, a teacup shatters on the ground. I look up and see an older woman standing at the marble counter, yelling at Mrs. Eldon, Ivy’s mother.
“This is too strong,” she shouts, shoving her pointer finger in Mrs. Eldon’s face. “I can feel you trying to compel me! No one drink the tea,” she says, turning to the other patrons in the shop. The room falls silent, all the conversation and clatter sucked up by the woman’s words. Ivy stands and goes to her mother’s side.
“I can assure you that all the tea in this shop adheres to each and every standard of low magic,” Mrs. Eldon says. “If you don’t like the particular blend you were given, we’d be happy to replace it with something more to your liking.”
“I’m no fool,” the woman says, her long gray ponytail swaying from side to side. “The problem isn’t the tea, it’s the magic. There is dark magic here, I can sense it.” She practically spits the words, and murmurs break out around the room. I’m shocked that she would be so bold. Dark magic hasn’t been on the island in years; it was all but eradicated with the new order.
Mrs. Eldon takes a step closer to the woman, her expression turning from patient to stern. “You are not to say those words in my shop. If you don’t like what we’re serving, you are free to leave, but I will not stand here and tolerate your disrespect.”
“All of you are being brainwashed. Each and every one,” the woman says, looking around the room. “You should be protesting the existence of this island, not putting silver in their pockets!”
“That’s enough,” Mrs. Eldon says. She walks to the front of the shop and holds open the door. “It’s time for you to go.”
“This place is an abomination. You should all be ashamed of yourselves.” The woman pushes past Ivy’s mother and out onto Main Street, leaving behind a heavy silence.
Mrs. Eldon takes a deep breath and closes the door, then turns to the other patrons. “I’m terribly sorry about that,” she says.
“For the record, I wish my tea was stronger,” says a man on the other side of the shop, and it’s enough to break the discomfort that had settled in the room.
People laugh, someone says, “Here, here!”， and then the rest of the customers raise their teacups in agreement, drinking to the idea of more magic, not less.
Mrs. Eldon smiles and walks back to the counter, but I see the way the confrontation weighs on her, the way her shoulders are drawn and her eyes are heavy with thought. Ivy and I haven’t seen many encounters like this—people come to the Witchery because they like magic. But our parents, and especially our grandparents, remember more frightening times when the majority of the mainland sought to get rid of magic altogether. They tell us the stories, remind us of how fortunate we are, but hearing it and seeing it are different things.
Ivy wraps an arm around her mother and whispers something in her ear. Mrs. Eldon nods, then excuses herself to the back room.
“Are you okay?” I ask, walking to where Ivy stands behind the counter, her eyes wet.
“I’m fine,” she says, wiping at her lashes. “These are angry tears. Seeing someone talk to my mom like that…” She trails off, unable to finish her sentence.
“I know,” I say, grabbing her hand. “Why come here if you hate magic?”
It’s easy to fall prey to the belief that the entire population of the mainland is like the regulars who visit the Witchery, but it isn’t true. How many people are on the mainland, looking across the Passage to our island, wanting it to go away? How many people still want the eradication of all magic? It’s scary, knowing that where there is one, there are others. And if those people got the ear of the governor, that would be terrifying.
I don’t believe there are many people who want us truly cut off from the mainland, who would be willing to burn our docks under the cover of darkness, but it’s becoming clear there are people who don’t want to live in a world where magic is accepted. Even magic ruled by the new order, gentle and mild, is too much for some. But in order to do away with magic, they would have to do away with us.