They pedaled along, and the grass was very green, and the sky was very blue, and it had been twenty entire minutes, and 4.3 miles, according to Sebastian’s Strava, since he’d thought about TikTok.
“You’re very easy to talk to,” he said.
“Thank you for ending that sentence with ‘to talk to,’？” Abby said. Sebastian thought for a few seconds, then snorted. Abby paused, then said, “You know, I’d hardly ever done anything like that before, the night we met. I’m really not a one-night-stand person.”
Sebastian wasn’t sure what to do with that information. If he’d been going on instinct—specifically, if he’d been going on the instinct telling him to do whatever it took to get together with Abby again—he’d have said It didn’t have to be a one-night stand. We can pick up right where we left off. Instead, he said, “Yeah. Same here.”
Abby turned her head to meet his gaze. Then she started laughing. Then he started laughing, too, and said, “Actually, I was a virgin when you met me. You took my maidenhead.”
“Do you want it back?” she asked. “And also, that can’t be true.”
“Why can’t it?”
“Well.” He thought that, if he could see her face, she’d be blushing; that delicious pink flush he remembered. “If I’d actually taken your maidenhead, wouldn’t we have had to do other things?”
“Other things?”
“You know,” Abby said. “Other things.” She lowered her voice to a stage whisper. “Butt stuff.”
“Butt stuff!” Sebastian repeated, laughing. “Oh my God.”
“Why is butt stuff funny?”
“Butt stuff,” said Sebastian, “is always funny.”
“Not the way I do it,” she said, in a pretend-sexy voice that sounded actually sexy to Sebastian, and because he was a guy, a guy who’d slept with her, he found himself picturing sexy things. And then, because he was a guy who was also trying to be friends with Abby, and not sleep with her again, he made himself stop picturing them, and forced himself, instead, to picture Abby with Mark.
Except he had no idea what Mark looked like. “Do you have a picture of Mark?” he asked as casually as he could.
Abby’s smile disappeared. “I can show you one when we stop,” she said. “He’s got dark hair and brown eyes, and he’s terrifyingly fit.”
“Terrifyingly fit?” Sebastian filed that away for future consideration.
“He runs six miles every single day.” Abby related this information calmly, but he thought he could hear something—was it envy? frustration?—underneath the factual tone.
“Six miles every day is a lot,” said Sebastian. “Is he training for a marathon?”
“Only if the marathon is his life. He’s done them before, though. And he’s a very clean eater. Lots of salmon and chicken breasts.”
This felt like a possible minefield, a place where it would be easy to say the wrong thing. So Sebastian said, “You guys met at summer camp?”
“It was actually a weight-loss camp. Fat camp.”
Another minefield, Sebastian thought. Avoid, avoid, avoid.
“Is he the same person he was when you were teenagers?” he asked.
Abby’s voice was very dry. “He’s about half the size he was back then. But yes, I’d say he’s very similar. Obviously he’s got more education now, and he’s lived more places, and done more things, but…” She pedaled and seemed to be thinking. “He’s always been kind. Bighearted. And he’s funny, in a kind of quiet way. That hasn’t changed. How about you?” she asked. “When was your last serious relationship?”
Sebastian didn’t want to tell her that there’d never been one; that, just as she was not a one-night-stand person, he’d never had more than a handful of hookups with the same woman. “It’s been a little while,” he said.
“Like, how long?”
He thought about saying college, or I can’t really remember. He thought of offering up COVID as an excuse. Instead, he told her, “I’ve never really had a serious girlfriend.”
“Wow,” said Abby. “What’s up with that? Like, who broke you?”
“No one broke me,” he said, a little indignantly.
“Are you sure?”
“I think I’d remember.”
“Not always,” Abby said. “Maybe you’ve repressed it.”