Fife grabs two and offers me the box, but I shake my head, passing on the pastries. The box gets set back on the table, and when I look up, Ellery and the Sullivan den are watching me.
“You should take one. They’re from Millie’s,” Brooks encourages, his voice rough and gravelly like he’s using it for the first time this morning.
“I’m good, thanks though,” I tell him.
“No really, you woke up dangerously fast,” Dillon counters.
“Even if you’re from a strong bloodline, you need to be careful,” Brooks contends, tired eyes imploring.
“You need all the calories you can get to support the transition,” Hank adds, pushing the box back across the table in my direction.
A low growl fills the room.
My head snaps in Ellery’s direction, whose angry blue-eyed gaze is fixed on the deputy. “Let my mate decide for herself,” he practically snarls.
Dillon throws his hands up in surrender, and his two other denmates grow tense and immediately drop their eyes to the table as if the wood grain is fascinating. “No offense. Sorry. Didn’t mean anything by it. I was just trying to help.”
The air is squeezed from the room like it’s an accordion. I gape at Ellery and the other den because what the hell was that?
Karen gives an amused snort and Ellery leans back in his chair and seems to force himself to take a deep breath and relax. As soon as he does, everyone else in the room lets the tension bleed from their frames, and the easygoing vibe that was just chased out of the room returns.
I step forward and quickly grab a muffin from the box, holding it in my hand and hoping it will help ease the last tendrils of tension floating around. It makes Dillon smile but has the opposite effect on Ellery. He suddenly looks pissed. His back straightens and I see him grip the pen so hard I’m surprised it doesn’t snap.
Immediately, I know I’ve made some kind of muffin or shifter faux pas, but I have no idea what. Maybe it was the muffin he wanted? But I can’t exactly put it back because I’ve touched it, and manners, so I just sit there as Ellery returns his attention to the Sullivan den.
“You three were at Droolies the night of the Hunt. You saw Noah there, correct?” he asks sternly.
All three men nod, looking from the sheriff to me and back again, confusion sprinkled across their faces.
“Several witnesses reported that you were watching her at the diner. Can you explain that?” Ellery presses.
“Witnesses?” Dillon asks, his brow furrowing. He looks around as though expecting one of the other deputies to explain, but no one does.
Hank clears his throat awkwardly. “We stopped in to grab a bite to eat before the Hunt. She…uh, Noah, is it?” he asks me, and I nod. “Well, Noah came in after we’d ordered and, well, she caught our attention,” he explains, waving a hand in my direction.
I fight the urge to slink down and hide beneath the table when everyone turns to look at me. It almost reminds me of the time in sixth grade that Mike told Tommy, who told Ginna, who told me that Mike thought I was the prettiest girl he’d ever seen. But pile on top of that an angry reaction from a celestial shifter who looks like he might rip the armrests off his chair. I feel like I just downed an entire bottle of awkward, and it burns like bleach.
“We were going to run, and like Dillon said, we overheard her talking to Zara about it, so we were being a little, I guess you could say, nosey,” he continues, embarrassment pinking his cheeks.
“And did you run?” Fife asks, stepping forward because Ellery looks ready to breathe fire.
Brooks dives into the conversation. “No. We planned on it, but I tweaked my back at work earlier—my team’s been renovating the old Aradia property. I thought I’d be fine, but when I went to shift, I threw it all the way out, and there was no way we could run,” he explains, leveling an apologetic look at his denmates. They both pat him reassuringly on the shoulder and back, and wave off his obvious chagrin.
“Bummer. You missed out on snagging Poodle here. She’s stuck with Ellery’s den now,” Karen says just before she takes a bite of her muffin.
“Tragedy,” Bucky jokes, but the Sullivan den goes stiff.
His comment feels like a dig at the den, but I’m not familiar enough with eerie dynamics to be sure. The angry glint in some of their eyes tells me I’m on the right track though. There must be some kind of history I don’t understand, because unlike the Bianchi den, these guys don’t seem so bad. Or maybe I’m just overthinking things, sensing insults where there are none because the cringey nature of this whole interview is invading my brain.
“I guess congrats are in order,” Brooks rasps, nodding at Ellery.
The sheriff gives a stiff nod of acknowledgement before turning his eyes to me. Fuck. The possessive look he gives me should be illegal. It’s the kind of look that makes women agree to all sorts of stupid things. Sure, you can handcuff me. Whips and chains? Sounds fun.
I drop my gaze to my muffin before my lower belly catches fire, because the last thing I want to be caught doing with an audience is eye-fucking the sheriff. Well, with this audience anyway. Karen is definitely the type to never let me live that down.
“Did you see the healer? For your back, I mean? Must have been bad if it wasn’t healing on its own,” Bucky asks before Ellery can muster up another question.
“Yeah, Imogen came by. It was better later that night,” Brooks answers.
Ellery writes something down on his pad, and from here I can just make out the words, check alibi and Imogen.
“Did you three notice anyone else in the diner who seemed interested in Noah? Anyone outside who might have been watching her when you left?” Fife inquires.
Dillon shrugs. “There were other dens there fueling up like we were, the McNeals and the Evanoras. I got the impression that they were curious too. I mean, she’s pretty and new, so that’s to be expected, ya know,” he explains, dropping his gaze and scratching at his arm.
“Anyone outside when you left?” Ellery asks again.
“Not that we noticed, but we weren’t exactly on the lookout,” Hank offers sheepishly.
“What’s this all about, sir?” Dillon demands, sitting up straighter and studying everyone more sharply. “Did someone hurt you?” he asks angrily, his intense stare suddenly trained on me.
“Someone stole Noah’s car,” Ellery starts.
“And threw the poor naif into the Hunt,” Fife adds. Ellery levels him with a glare.
Come the fuck on, Fife. He definitely shouldn’t have said that. Even I know better. But my reaction is nothing compared to the Sullivan den’s.
“Oh shit,” Dillon exclaims at the same time Brooks asks, “Naif?” Their muscles grow tight with anger, and each member radiates outrage.
“Don’t you dare wolf out in here,” Karen orders, scooting sideways along the wall like she doesn’t want wolf germs.
The red crystals on the table strobe brighter, and the Sullivan den winces.
“That’s…that’s fucked-up,” Dillon growls. “What are we doing?” he demands, as though the need to take immediate action is riding him hard.
My eyes sting with sudden emotion at their response.