“It was nice to see you, Jacob.” I can hear my voice shake at the end.
“You, too, Sadie.” He gives me a crooked smile and looks away.
“Well, I should go.” I repeat, slowly taking another step back. As I turn and head back across the café toward the door, I can still smell his cinnamony Jacob-scent, so familiar to me now. And just like that piano song he played on New Year’s Eve, it lingers around me long after I’ve left.
Chapter 11
What do you think—Thai or Indian?” Alex slides open a kitchen drawer and grabs a stack of take-out menus. With just the slightest push of his hand, the drawer slides back silently on its track, catching at the end so it doesn’t slam into the frame like the ones in my apartment do. He holds out the crumpled, oil-stained papers, and I’m surprised he allowed them into this pristine space.
Unlike my place with its mismatched furniture, cluttered array of abandoned earrings and Post-it note grocery lists on the coffee table, and shoes spilling from the closet, Alex’s brand-new downtown apartment is sleek and minimalist. Until last summer, he lived in student housing at Columbia with two other guys from his program, so this place is quite an upgrade, one he could afford thanks to his investment banker salary. It’s a couple of blocks away from his Wall Street office building and around the corner from the high-end bars where they all like to hang out after work.
Alex hired his boss’s decorator to furnish the place in dark leather, chrome, and mahogany, and when I brought in a bright orange throw pillow to add a pop of color to the couch, it mysteriously disappeared a couple of weeks later. Alex never seemed like the kind of guy to hang a blank canvas smeared with gray paint on his wall, let alone to call it art. But now that I’ve been to Zach’s place for that New Year’s party, it all makes a little more sense. If you switched around the floor plan and exchanged the dark gray canvas for a light gray one, this apartment could belong to any number of Alex’s investment banker friends. They even share the same cleaning woman who makes the rounds once a week to keep their apartments looking as austere as the MoMA.
I choose Thai food, and Alex places our order, then hands me a glass of my favorite sauvignon blanc. He always keeps a couple of bottles in the wine fridge for me, even though he doesn’t drink it, and he bought a set of stemless glasses when he noticed I prefer them. Aside from the orange pillow incident, Alex has always gone out of his way to make sure I’m comfortable here. I was charmed the first time I found my favorite shampoo and body wash in his shower, and he keeps the pantry stocked with flour and icing sugar even though it drives him crazy to watch me sprinkle it across his dark marble countertops like a snowstorm blowing across Mount Everest.
To be honest, I’m probably the reason he hired the cleaning woman.
Alex neatly stacks the menus back in the drawer and we settle on the couch with our drinks.
“Bake anything good this week?” Alex asks, taking a sip of the whiskey in his glass.
I tell him about my newest creation: mini saffron Bundt cakes covered in a rich chocolate coconut ganache and decorated with candied grapefruit peel. “I may just have one in my bag for you,” I say. “For after dinner, of course.”
Alex grins and runs his palm up my thigh. “I was thinking of a different kind of dessert.”
I lean over to give him a quick kiss, but before he can tug me closer, I slip off the couch and grab my bag from the chair across the room. “I’ll put this on the counter for you.” I hold up the cake box.
His brow furrows, and I know he’s probably wondering what’s going on with me. Before my Very Bad Year ruined everything, our sex life was pretty great. In his version of reality, nothing should have changed. But ever since I woke up to find myself in this wild time loop, I’ve been hesitant when it comes to intimacy, and I can’t quite explain why.
Maybe it’s because I’m still getting used to having him around after all those months apart. Or maybe it’s because I remember how much it hurt when he walked away.
Luckily, we’ve both been busy at work, and our schedules haven’t matched up very well, so it hasn’t been an issue yet. But I need to get past this before it becomes one. I cross the room back to Alex, reminding myself that this is my second chance year, and Alex won’t be walking away again. I plan to do everything right this time around.
Just as I sit down and reach for Alex’s hand, my phone rings, and the word Home pops up on the screen. I sigh, realizing my mistake. I’d mentioned to my mom that I’d be at Alex’s tonight, and the surefire way to get my parents’ attention is to mention Alex. I bet they’ve been waiting by the phone for the right time to call all evening.
“Hi, Sadie,” my mom says after I’ve answered the phone. The volume of her voice rises and falls, probably because she has the phone set to speaker so my dad can participate. “Is Alex there?”
At least she gets straight to the point. Where’s Alex? How’s Alex’s high-powered job? No sense in pretending they’re interested in what’s going on in my life. How much is there to say about brownies and cupcakes, anyway?
My mom is the dean of the literature department at Rutgers University and a renowned expert in nineteenth-century women’s literature, and my dad literally wrote the textbook on ancient Greek translation. In my childhood, it was normal for me to come home from soccer practice to find my parents and their professor friends drinking red wine in the living room and discussing George Eliot’s influence on modern feminism or the symbolism in Homer’s The Odyssey.
With a whole alphabet of letters after their names, it was only natural my parents expected Owen and me to go to college and then graduate school. And in my brother, they got everything they ever wished for. He tested into the school’s gifted program when he was in first grade, earned straight As all through middle and high school, and had his pick of Ivy League universities after graduation.
And then there was me.
Let’s just say I was well into high school before I realized The Odyssey isn’t part of the Star Wars trilogy. School just wasn’t my thing, and I couldn’t pretend it was.
I landed a job working the cash register at a bakery when I was fifteen, and that’s where I found my passion. Bread, cookies, cakes, tarts, I loved them all equally. And when the head chef broke her femur in a fly-fishing accident and was laid up for a month, I got my big break in the kitchen. My parents indulged me for a while—after all, who doesn’t love a three-tiered banana cake with hazelnut and chocolate frosting? But when I stopped thinking of baking as a hobby and started to believe it could be my career, they were devastated. You’d think I’d gone into the adult entertainment industry the way they still can’t really talk about it. I’m pretty sure their favorite thing about me is my boyfriend.
“Alex is right here, Mom.” I switch my phone to speaker and hand it to Alex, mouthing, “I’m sorry.”
He grins and shakes his head like it’s no big deal. I’m reminded of how lucky I am to have him back in my life.
“Alex, how are you, son?” my dad’s voice cuts into my thoughts.
Alex leans over the phone. “I’m good, Jim. How are you?”